School Should Never Be Real Life


cc licensed ( BY NC SD ) flickr photo shared by vasta

I haven’t been able to peruse Twitter as much lately, coaching and parenting have dominated my time, both very rewarding and a lot of fun but both are big commitments that will keep me from things like Twitter and blogging. Yesterday, I did get a chance to pop on, read a few interesting articles and blog posts. One post I saw talked about how a certain activity was more like “real life” and then comments about how school SHOULD be real life.

Real life. When we are talking about how we want to prepare our students for the “real world” or for their future careers, I get it. We are all for creating the “target context” and for developing practical 21st century skills. We are all on board when it comes to helping our students become well rounded, creative, active learners who will be successful in life when they leave us and contribute in a positive way to society. When it comes to those ideas of “real life” then there will be little argument from most educators.

But “real life” or the “real world” has a lot going on that I never want to see in our buildings. As we try to bring more and more of everyday life into our schools and make them more and more like the world our students will enter we have to be cognizant of ensuring we still provide a place that our students can grow and learn. We need to ensure our buildings remain safe, fair, supportive, collaborative and welcoming to all students.

Our world is not safe, especially for minorities, and while that is “real life” we all work hard every day to protect our students from bullying, intolerance, and abuse. Our society is far from fair, competition is everywhere and its ridiculous to think everyone begins the race from the same starting line. There are many workplaces where support and collaboration go against the very goals they strive for, whether its sales numbers or innovation, but pushing that type competition into our schools is to take away a huge asset to development and learning.

Don’t get me wrong, I know our job is to prepare our students for the world of tomorrow. They need the skills and knowledge we help develop to be successful and to contribute in a meaningful way, but learning can and should get messy. Our students will make mistakes and learn to move past them, but in a place where the care, the support and the guidance is there to help them get beyond their difficulties. They have to feel safe, supported and cared for and they need to trust their guides that put them back on the right path. That requires a place that creates those feelings and provides those guides. School should never be real life, because many of our students won’t find those feelings or those mentors anywhere except school.

4 thoughts on “School Should Never Be Real Life

  1. I sorta understand that school must go beyond todays real life. Having said that, school must also be real using quality real life experiences to go beynd the real life of today. Clearly book learned students will move on w/o a lick of common sense. Combine the book learned with real and you have the model for success

  2. The problem with this idea is that school is real life for kids right now. If a kid comes from a broken home or is dealing with issues, do we say that it doesn’t count until they get a job? Yes we have to ensure our kids are safe, but in real life, we have to do that for our staff as well. The caring environment that you talk about should exist in all organizations as people could flourish in these type of conditions.

    When we use “relevant” as opposed to “real” are we not discrediting what students are going through right now?

    Just my thoughts.

    • I read it more as school should strive to be what the world isn’t able to be. It should be more fair, safe and equitable than the ‘real world’. I didn’t read that schools should ignore the reality of their students, but rather if they are students that for one reason or many don’t live in privilege in the real world, that they would be able to expect a safe, respectful and fair environment at school, even if that’s the only place they can expect that.

  3. Jessie, I see your argument and I agree that school should be a safe environment, etc. However, I think we’d be doing our students a disservice if we didn’t prepare them for real life, which isn’t the same as allowing that “real life” to be what they experience at school.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s